Sure, but my objection to Saw III or Saw IV, doesn't solely concern its realistic violence. Hell, I am sure there is fiction where I enjoyed realistic gore. The purpose that Saw's violence serves is elaborate torture.
Watching a zombie eat a human being's guts doesn't bother me... but watching a thirty minute sequence where a person's appendages are slowly twisted till they break, while he screams his lungs off, is pretty sickening to me. It is just a few notches above watching a long and violent acted rape sequence, even if it is for the horror -- it is just mentally depraved.
I don't care what hyper realistically ultra violent piece of fiction anyone enjoys... hell I'll probably enjoy it too. But come on, sure sadism crosses the boundary. Heck, I even have trouble classifying some of this torture porn as horror.
Yeah. Fake gore doesn't bother me, but real stuff makes me sick to my stomach. Like watching some of the old riot videos of the 90s, and when that truck driver got beat to death with a brick. That makes me ill. Pictures of the holocaust, same. Fake movie crap? Who cares, it's makeup. Sometimes I find the concepts disturbing (I debated watching Hostel and eventually just said forget it, the premise was a bit much for me). But something like Saw is just a cartoon, a caricature, a comic book. At best.
I don't know, but neither of the first two saw movies bothered me. Then I saw a few sequences of Saw III on TV, and then caught a few glimpses of Saw IV another time, and noticed that they had really pushed the ante.
Also, I haven't heard of his truck driver thing, but I am glad I haven't seen it.
One time, back when P2P was new, I downloaded this Lion attack video, thinking it would be some cool documentary clip. Turned out, it was a recovered film from a family handicam, where they are out on a safari when the husband goes out to take some pictures, and some lions attack him. The video was being shot from within the family's jeep, and well, it was all pretty disgusting. While the clip lacked audio, you could see the kids crying while the lions ate the guy.
To this day, I am still not sure if it was 100% real, but it made me really really sick.